In modern software development, Unique Identifier is an important component that forms the basis of the system. Whether it's a database primary key, API resource identification, user ID, order number or file name, we need a reliable mechanism to generate unique identifiers.
UUID: The most widely used standard
UUID (Universally Unique Identifier) is a set of 128-bit identification code standards (RFC 4122). Its design goal is to ensure global uniqueness without the need for a central coordination mechanism. The most common UUID v4 relies entirely on random numbers, while the newer UUID v7 combines timestamps and random numbers to provide time-ordered features.
The advantage of UUID is that it has the highest degree of standardization and is natively supported by almost all programming languages and databases, making it very suitable for cross-system and cross-language application scenarios. However, its 36-character length can be verbose in some situations, and the purely random nature of v4 is not friendly to database indexes.
ULID: A modern alternative to sortable
ULID (Universally Unique Lexicographically Sortable Identifier) was proposed by Alizain Feerasta in 2016 to solve the problem of UUID being unsortable. The ULID is also 128 bits, but encoded as a 26-character Crockford Base32 string. Its timestamp prefix ensures that a lexicographic sort is a chronological sort and can produce up to 2^80 unique values in the same millisecond.
The additional benefit of Crockford Base32 encoding is that it excludes easily confused characters (such as I, L, O, U), improving the accuracy of human reading and manual input. The case-insensitivity of ULIDs also makes them friendlier when used in URLs.
Nano ID: lightweight and efficient solution
Nano ID was developed by Andrey Sitnik (also the author of PostCSS and Autoprefixer) and is one of the most popular ID generators in the front-end ecosystem. Unlike UUID and ULID, Nano ID is not a fixed format standard, but a customizable implementation. Its core design philosophy is to "provide sufficient uniqueness in the smallest size."
Nano ID uses a 64-character URL safe alphabet (including A-Z, a-z, 0-9, - and _), and provides the same 126 bits of randomness as UUID v4 at a default length of 21 characters. By adjusting the length parameter, you can flexibly switch between safety and simplicity.
CUID2: horizontally extended anti-collision scheme
CUID2 is the second-generation version of CUID, built by Eric Elliott and specifically designed for horizontal scaling (Horizontal Scaling) scenarios. CUID2 internally uses incrementing counters, random fingerprints, and hash functions to ensure that collisions will not occur even in a decentralized system without a central coordinator.
The default length of CUID2 is about 24 characters and contains encoded fingerprint information, so even if two servers generate IDs within the same millisecond, the results will be completely different. This makes CUID2 ideal for microservice architectures and serverless applications.
How to choose? Practical suggestions
If you are creating a new PostgreSQL or MySQL table and want to use UUID as the primary key,It is strongly recommended to choose UUID v7, which can significantly reduce index fragmentation problems. If you need to expose the ID to the outside world and want it to be shorter,ULID or Nano ID is a better choice. For horizontal expansion scenarios with extremely high security requirements,CUID2 Provides additional protection against collisions.
No matter which format you choose, you can use ToolHub's ID generator to quickly generate test data and verify that your choice meets your business needs with the collision probability calculator.